Court Holds Montgomery County's 'Feet to the Fire'

Citizens' groups were elated at a ruling that county government failed to open its records in a land-use case.


Three citizens' groups have won a lawsuit alleging Montgomery County failed to turn over documents the residents sought in a campaign to keep an organic farm in Potomac from being turned into soccer fields.

The Montgomery County Circuit Court Tuesday sided with the West Montgomery County Citizens' Association, the Civic Association of River Falls and the Brickyard Coalition in ordering Montgomery County Executive Isiah Leggett to repeat a search for public documents related to the Brickyard Road controversy.

“[Tuesday] was a big win for us,” said Ginny Barnes, environmental chair of the West Montgomery County Citizens Association.

Sign up for the Potomac Patch newsletter to have headlines sent straight to your inbox.

The groups filed the lawsuit in March had not adequately responded to a Nov. 9, 2011 public information request. The county had continued to produce documents through the time of the hearing, well past the six-month deadline assigned by law.

The civic groups’ request asked for county documents and correspondence pertaining to the county's handling of the Brickyard Road Middle School site in Potomac. The land had been farmed by Nick Maravell of Nick's Organic Farm for 30 years before the Montgomery County Board of Education decided in March of 2011 not to renew Maravell's lease and instead lease the land to the county to develop into soccer fields.

Open Government Violations

The Brickyard Coalition has with the county's public notification process in the Brickyard issue, and in 2011 the Maryland Open Meetings Law Compliance Board found that county residents were not made sufficiently aware of the proceedings. in July 2011 claiming that the Open Meetings Act was violated and that the court should therefore reject the county’s claim on the land. before the case was to be heard.

The Montgomery County Circuit Court on Tuesday denied the county's motion to dismiss the public information suit and ordered the Montgomery County executive branch to redo the search for documents. This time the search is to be supervised by both the county and the Brickyard proponents.

Circuit Court Judge Ronald Rubin ordered that the civic groups and the county work out search criteria together by July 20. Judge Rubin also ordered the search to be conducted by the county technology department, which will look at all computers and servers for the records requested. According to Montgomery County spokesman Patrick Lacefield, the county suggested the technology department’s involvement.

“We are happy to bend over backwards to make sure that responsive email information is found,” he said.

The ordered search is to be completed by Aug. 3. After allowing time for review of the documents, the hearing will continue on Aug. 14.

The High Price of Information

Freedom of information lawsuits such as these are fairly common with federal public information laws, but less common under state laws regulating government transparency, according to Nathan Siegel, professor and public information expert at the University of Maryland Francis King Carey School of Law.

The suits are often expensive and time consuming, he said, keeping the price for going after desired information fairly high.

“It is difficult to prove an office has documents you think they have when they say they don’t,” Siegel said. “One way to avoid producing documents is not to do a thorough search.”

Lack of adequate searching is more commonly an issue with high numbers of documents, Siegel said.

Civic organizations in the Brickyard case are requesting all documents pertaining to the Brickyard soccer field project, the scope of which ranges from at least 12 county employees, and from emails to calendar items and memos, according to coalition member Curt Uhre.

According to Patrick Lacefield, the county’s stuttered response to the information request was  an oversight.

“In doing affidavits for [the] hearing, some additional emails were found that may have not been found before,” Lacefield said.

Brickyard Coalition members disagree, saying the county continues to withhold important documents detailing how the Brickyard Road deal came to pass. In some cases, the coalition alleges that the county misled it about lost documents such as an initial letter written by Leggett to the Board of Education asking to lease the land to the county.

Uhre said that while the county claims it can’t find the original document, it has sent a copy of the letter as attached to an earlier complaint of county conduct by Maravell.

Now that the Montgomery County Department of Technology Services will conduct the new information search, the civic groups are hopeful that any lost documents will be quickly recovered.

"This is a huge victory for the citizens of Montgomery County," Uhre said. "We're hoping the county will now in good faith do what the court has ordered them to do."

There are few legal reasons why the county wouldn’t produce the documents, and the most common of these are exemptions to the law allowing officials to withhold information, according to Siegel. Exemptions to public information requests include criminal investigations, personnel records and documents alleged to contain personal information. In the event that the county claims any of the exemptions, it would have to give reasons for why it is excluded and a description of what the document contains.

“It is a positive development when courts hold government officials’ feet to the fire to perform basic obligations,” Siegel said.

Follow us on Twitter and Facebook for breaking news updates.

organic friend July 11, 2012 at 03:01 PM
Can you imagine trusting your government? I don't know why I still think they will act in good faith. So, for the sake of soccer fields, our County officials have mislead, broken the law (open meetings law, RFP process), withheld information, forced citizens to court to get them to provide information (as the article says, manipulating the process to defeat citizens by upping the cost of information), and tried to gag our voice. Really, for soccer fields???? what is going on here? 50,000 people support the farm but our trusted leaders have decided on soccer fields???
Democracy Works July 12, 2012 at 04:24 PM
I can imagine Patrick Lacefield telling the County Technology Department to delete all records from Parks & Planning, Community Events, the Recreation Department that helps schedule MSI Soccer games, Maintenance and Operations, and of course, the Administrative offices. Mr. Lacefield has a love affair with MSI Soccer and their money.
Peter Meier July 14, 2012 at 07:54 PM
First, let's be clear these are not "Citizen's Groups" that are purusing this lawsuit. These are three advocacy groups. They are clearly well run and well funded, and were formed to serve their members interests in keeping traffic and development out of their neighborhood. It is certainly their right to advocate their position, but spare us the euphemisms. Second, the FOIA requests are all about delaying and derailing the County's efforts. It is not a search for truth in any real sense, but simply a litigation tactic. Again, that is their right under our legal system, but no need for high falutin' pretentions. Finally, on the substance of the issue, yes, I happen to think that the County has the right to lease its land in the manner it believes serves the greatest good. Opponents can exact their retribution in the next election.
Jim Burnetti July 14, 2012 at 08:15 PM
Brickyard Road residents need to become citizens of Montogomery County. Their new homes were built on a through street. They knew that - yet they line their street with speed bumps and traffic circles - pretending they built on a cul de sac that no one ever used before they were there. Now they don't want the rabble in their neighborhood. Time for you to become members of the larger community.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »